[Previous entry: "Rachel Caine's HEAT STROKE--Really Something (Linda)"] [Main Index] [Next entry: "INCUBUS DREAMS--Anita "Does" St. Louis (Shelley)"]

09/28/2004 Entry: "Mercedes Lackey's PHOENIX AND ASHES--While-Away-the-Hours Good (Preeti)"

Phoenix and Shadows

Mercedes Lackey's PHOENIX AND ASHES sets the Cinderella fairy tale in WWI England. I think it's the novelty of the setting that hooked me, the romance of a wartime era that I haven't encountered in my reading too often. Plus the story was more readable than other Lackeys I've tried.

Eleanor Robinson is a bright young Englishwoman denied a chance to study at Oxford as promised, and even to have a decent life, after her doting industrialist father suddenly marries a wicked woman and transfers all his attention and affection to her. Upon his death, Eleanor's stepmother, a powerful elemental master of earth, brutally and magically binds her to the hearth in her home in order to bilk her of her inheritance. She also makes the townspeople forget about Eleanor.

Reginald Fenyx is local gentry and someone who was a friend to Eleanor during her childhood despite their different social strata. A WWI pilot, he's also an elemental master of air. Now he's back in the countryside recuperating from an accident. He and Eleanor manage to reconnect and fall in love, except that he doesn't know how hellish her life has become.

Eleanor has to find a way to free herself, defeat her stepmother, and come into her own powers. And nab her prince, of course. All along the way, the script of a darker version of Cinderella is followed. For example, instead of glass slippers, we have a four-fingered glove, and a gruesome twist to the tale that is.

I liked the plot, and I liked all the characters. I rooted for Eleanor and couldn't wait to see the eeevvil stepmother, Alison, get her just deserts. What more can you hope for from a fairy tale retelling? (Don't answer.) This was a basic and fun story with just enough new elements to keep me happy.

Overall, I recommend PHOENIX AND ASHES. Reading it whiled away several hours enjoyably.--Preeti

--PHOENIX AND ASHES review page
--THE SERPENT'S SHADOW (recent Elemental Masters book) review page
--THE FIRE ROSE (first Elemental Masters book) review page
--PHOENIX AND ASHES at Amazon

Replies: 2 Comments

On something of a tangent (addressing the setting comment) Eva Ibbotson has several of her earlier romances set in the era between WWI and II, and I agree--the setting was definitely one of the things that helped make those books memorable for me. (although Ibbotson's romance formula is old-school enough that every so often-maybe 1 of 3 books or so- I root for her to wise up and find a guy who's not so... so... you just don't let 'em _treat_ you like that, even if they are smart and funny and charming as hell.)

Posted by megd @ 10/17/2004 10:08 AM ET


I loved the one Eva Ibbotson historical fiction book I've read, A COUNTESS BELOW STAIRS. I thought it was charming. Well, I did read THE MORNING GIFT, but that seemed more serious somehow, and I wasn't looking for serious.

Alas, it seems to me like she's only writing children's fantasy these days. (Probably getting paid loads more to do so!) Too bad she doesn't mix it up a little, i.e., combining fantasy with romantic historical fiction. You know she'd have a market in us at least!

Posted by Preeti @ 10/21/2004 06:14 PM ET



Back to Top | About Us